Also available as PDF (figures and tables appear in the PDF).
Objective: To compare the effects of resisted exercise in lungs volume and capacity and strength of the respiratory muscles on individuals with hemiparesis after a stroke. Methods: Ten individuals with hemiparesis caused by stroke were evaluated by measuring thoracic cirtometry, spirometry and manovacuometry before and after a muscle strengthening program for upper and lower limb that consisted of three weekly sessions with progressive load increment (30, 40 and 50% of the maximum load). The pre and post intervention data were compared using the t-Student and Wilcoxon tests (p<0.05). Results: The subjects assessed were 52.60±10.50 years old, 70% were men and 70% with right hemisphere damage. These are the pre and post intervention data concerning respectively to axillary thoracic mobility= 4.40±1.20 and 4.20±1.57 cm; xiphoid=4.45±1.34 and 4.90±1.76 cm; basal=4.00±1.68 and 4.25±2.52 cm, spirometry: FVC=3,52±0,57 L e 3,30±0,64 L; FVC%=93,06±9,77 e 86,81±14,06%; FEV1=2,72±0,49 L e 2.58±0.59 L; FEV1%=88.27±9.43 e 83.04±15.08%; FEV1/FVC=83.62±10.62 e 78.70±13.74%; Pimax=-88.50±24.27 e -91.50±21.09 cm H2O; Pemax = 96.00±23.78 e 95.50±15.71 cm H2O. After the training period with resisted exercise there was a statistically significant improvement on peripheral muscle strength (p<0.05). However, the variables associated with the respiratory function remained similar (p>0.05). Conclusions: Adaptations caused by the resisted exercise training did not promote variation in thoracic expansion and respiratory muscles strength, as well as in lungs volume and capacity on subjects at a stroke chronic phase.KEYWORDS: ; ; ;
Keywords: Respiratory mechanics; Stroke; Muscle strength; Physical therapy
After the approval of the Research Ethics Committee from the institution (document 0093/2011) a prospective and interventionist study was performed, where seventy volunteers were sorted after a previous diffusion of the research in health units, places with wide movement of people and local means of
communication. Seventeen fulfilled the inclusion criterion and, among them, ten concluded the research protocol. The inclusion criterion were: (1) subjects over 18 years old, (2) unilateral cerebrovascular lesion, for at least six months, associated with hemiparesis, (3) ability to understand verbal instructions, (4) ability to stay in orthostatic position without auxiliary means, (5) no significant orthopedic and neurological alterations prior to the stroke. Subjects who were incapable of understanding or performing the required activities were not included. All the subjects who passed the inclusion criterion signed the Informed and Consent Form.
The selected subjects undertook an assessment performed in three days. On the first day, anamnesis, body weight and height, cirtometry, spirometry and manovacuometry were performed. On the second and third assessment days, a one maximum repetition test (1RM) was performed and, after 72 hours, the muscle strengthening program for upper and lower limb started.
The body weight was performed on a digital weighing ® 10,11 machine (Filizola® brand) and height was taken on a stadiometer device, attached to the weighing machine. The Body Mass Index (BMI) was calculated with these data by dividing the body 12,13 14 weight (kg) by the squared height (m2).
For the thoracic cirtometry, the subject stood up straight with the upper limbs extended along the body. A measuring tape was used to measure the axillary, xiphoid and basal regions. Each measurement was taken after a maximum expiration, followed by a maximum inspiration and another maximum expiration. The difference between the maximum inspiration and expiration was taken as the thoracic expansibility. Measurements were repeated twice in each region, and only the highest values were considered.
The spirometry was performed according to the criteria of the American Thoracic Society (ATS), on a spirometer (Digital One Flow FVC Kit Function System 1070) and three forced vital capacity tests were performed, reproductive and acceptable. The FVC and FEV1 in liters and the predicted percentage were obtained as well as the relation FVC/FEV1 in percentage.17
The assessment of the respiratory muscles strength was
sure measures, MIP and MEP. The patient remained seated, with hips on 90º and straight stem. Nares were occluded by a nasal clip and the same was done with the mouth between teeth and lips, in order to avoid air escape. A forced inspiration from the residual volume was requested to obtain MIP and a forced expiration from the total lungs capacity was requested to obtain MEP. The procedures were repeated three times and the highest value was considered for the analysis.18
In order to perform the training program, a one maximum repetition test (1RM) was performed with progressive load increment until obtaining the highest dislocated load on the total articular range in the eccentric and concentric phases, without support in all the exercises. The following muscle groups were tested: elbow flexors and extensors, shoulder horizontal adductors and abductors, shoulder abductors, knee flexors and extensors, hip flexors and extensors. The maximum strength tests were performed in two days; five exercises a day, randomly chosen, starting on the paretic and non paretic sides. Upper limb exercises were interspersed with lower limb exercises.
The training program was conducted in three weekly sessions for twelve weeks. The program consisted of exercises performed on an opened kinetic chain using mechano-therapy equipments: elbow flexion (biceps curl bench and dumbbells); elbow extension (dumbbells); shoulder horizontal adduction (pec deck); shoulder horizontal abduction (reverse pec deck); shoulder abduction (dumb bells); knee flexion (leg extension machine); knee extension (leg extension machine); hip adduction (adduction/abduction machine) and hip abduction (adduction/abduction machine), performed unilaterally (paretic side). In the first week, the training was performed with 30% of 1RM, in the second week 40% and in the following weeks 50% of 1RM. In the end of each month, the volunteers took the 1RM test again and the training loads were adjusted. A five-minute warm up was performed before every resisted training. After the trainings, also in every session, there was a 5 minute relaxation.
Blood pressure and heart rate were monitored in the beginning and in the end of the sessions. After performing the training protocol, patients were reassessed.
The descriptive statistics was used for the characterization of the sample and data presented in mean and standard deviation. The variables went through a Shapiro-Wilk normality test. The ones which presented normal distribution were compared with a t-student test and those which didn’t present normal distribution were compared with a Wilcoxon test, with a 5% level of significance. The statistical software BioEstat 5.0 was used for all the analysis.
Ten subjects were assessed, 70% of them were men.
They were 52.60±10.50 years old, they had 82.10±18.05 kg of body weight, 1.69±7.31 m of height and they also had 28.70±5.99 kg/m2 of BMI. The cerebrovascular lesion time was 40.60±29.56 months, and 70% of them presented right hemiparesis.
The thoracic mobility, as well as the spirometric variables and maximum respiratory pressures didn’t show significant differences in the sample when compared to the assessments before and after the muscle strengthening program (Table 1).
Caxillary (cm) 4.40±1.20 4.20±1.57 0.34
Cxiphoid (cm) 4.45±1.34 4.90±1.76 0.09
Cbasal (cm) 4.00±1.68 4.25±2,52 0.33
FVC (L) 3.52±0.57 3.30±0.64 0.06
FVC (%) 93.06±9.77 86.81±14.06 0.06 FEV1 (L) 2.72±0.49 2.58±0,59 0.08
FEV1 (%) 88.27±9.43 83.04±15,08 0.07 FEV1/FVC (%) 83.62±10.62 78.70±13,74 0.09 MIP (cmH O) -88.50±24.27 -91.50±21.09 0.24
MEP (cmH2O) 96.00±23.78 95.50±15.71 0.47 Caxillary: axillary cirtometry; C xiphoid: xiphoid cirtometry; C basal: basal cirtometry; FVC: Forced Vital Capacity; FEV1: Forced Expiratory Volume in the first second); FEV /FVC: relation between forced expiratory volume in the first second and forced vital capacity; MIP: Maximum Inspiratory Pressure; MEP: Maximum Expiratory Pressure; L: Liters); cm: Centimeters); %: Percentage over the predict; cm H2O: water centimeters)
Table 1. Comparison of the variables before and after the muscle strengthening program.
On the 1RM test in the paretic side, there was improvement in every muscle group assessed, except on elbow and knee flexors and knee extensors (Table 2).
Elbow flexors 5.50±3.72 7.22±4.68 0.09
Elbow extensors 3.20±2.86 4.44±2.13 0.03 Shoulder abductors 2.40±2.88 3.70±2.00 0.02 Horizontal abductors 12.50±10.61 17.50±13.59 0.02
Horizontal adductors 16.50±14.54 26.50±15.99 <0.01
Knee flexors 16.22±13.45 18.78±13.31 0.10
Knee extensors 7.00±4.38 8.13±4.58 0.20
Hip abductors 34.00±19.26 44.50±18.33 <0.01
Hip adductors 47.00±24.97 58.00±21.37 0.02
Table 2. Comparison of the 1 RM test in kilograms on the paretic side, before and after the muscle strengthening program.
In the non paretic side there was improvement on elbow flexors and extensors and hip abductors (Table 3).
Elbow flexors 10.50±4.45 12.11±5.11 0.02
Elbow extensors 8.70±2.75 7.56±2.83 0.01 Shoulder abductors 5.20±2.15 5.20±1.87 0.50 Horizontal abductors 25.50±7.62 29.50±11.41 0.07
Horizontal adductors 29.00±9.66 28.00±12.29 0.38
Knee flexors 19.50±13.01 20.50±11.65 0.17
Knee extensors 12.50±6.77 13.00±6.32 0.29
Hip abductors 39.00±20.39 44.50±18.17 0.02
Hip adductors 57.00±20.84 56.50±19.30 0.36
Table 3. Comparison of the 1RM test in kilograms on the non paretic side, before and after the muscle strengthening program.
Analyzing the effects of the resisted exercise in the studied variables, no significant differences were found in thoracic mobility as well as in lungs volume and capacity and strength of the respiratory muscles, even though there was improvement in the muscle groups trained.
The studied sample was composed, in its majority, by male subjects, which confirms studies that point to a greater 20,21 stroke incidence on men. Concerning age, the mean was 52.60±10.50 years old, indicating that the studied sample can 22,23 suffer the aging harmful effects besides the hemiparesis that can interfere in a negative way in the variables after the muscle strengthening. It’s known that aging leads to a reduction on innervation, capilar density, number and size of muscle fibers and therefore substitution of the muscle tissue for non contractile tissue, bringing reduction on peripheral muscle strength and less fatigue resistance.22 These factors may have interfered on muscle strength gain in lower limbs in this sample.
Concerning the respiratory system, studies show that aging leads to a reduction in the number of alveolus and pulmonary compliance, raise in thoracic anteroposterior diameter and thoracic kiphosis in a way that there is a reduction in the pulmonary function.23 The majority of the subjects were over 50 years old, besides that, we believe that age hasn’t influenced the results of pulmonary function since all of them were according to the normality parameters.
The majority of subjects showed right-sided hemiparesis indicating left-sided cerebral lesion. There is no consensus in the literature about the most affected hemisphere. What is known is that the left hemisphere is dominant for the motor control, that is, motor activities are more damaged in subjects with left-sided
recovery when comparing to subjects with right-sided lesion.24 As the sample was mostly composed by subjects with left-sided cerebral lesion, we believe that the damaged hemisphere may have been one of the factors that contributed to our results, as well as the training applied, which didn’t aim the respiratory muscles specifically.
Thoracic expansibility alteration allows us to infer that there is also change in the volume of mobilized air during respiration.25 Thus, the asymmetry in the respiratory dynamics, as it happens in the hemiparesis, is going to lead to a reduction in the thoracic mobility because of the movement restriction of the paretic hemithorax, being the lower thoracic region the most restricted.26 The reference values for the thoracic cirtometry vary 16,27 between 4 to 11 centimeters. In this study, subjects presented less than 4 centimeters of mean in the thoracic basal region. Other assessed regions showed thoracic expansibility close to 4 centimeters. The thoracic expansibility didn’t show significant difference after the training program, which is attributed to the non significant alteration of the respiratory muscles strength, which would lead to a lung volume increment. In the sample, as there was no significant increment in the strength of the respiratory muscles, the thoracic expansibility also didn’t show significant alteration after the muscle strengthening program.
The analysis of the spirometric variables before the program indicates that the sample presents normal values, which goes against the literature information that shows that hemiparetic individuals present pulmonary ventilatory restrictive defect, characterized by a reduction of FVC and FEV1, with FEV1/ FVC values close to the normality. After the muscle strengthening, there was no significant alteration of lungs volume and capacity, besides the reduction in the thoracic expansibility when 16,27 compared to the normality. The strength of the respiratory muscles can also have interfered on lungs capacity and volume during the FVC test.
Concerning strength of the respiratory muscles, the obtained values were according to the normality, which can be justified by the compensation strategies to maintain pulmonary function that are developed by individuals with chronic hemiparesis, such as higher muscle recruitment on the non paretic side and use of accessory muscles.28 In the present study, the maximum respiratory pressures showed a slight increment after the muscle strengthening program, but this value was not statistically relevant. The muscle training program performed didn’t aim specifically the increment of the respiratory muscles strength and, even though it involved the scapular waist muscle, it was not able to change the strength of the respiratory muscles in a significant way. It’s important to highlight that the resisted exercise didn’t influence, in a positive or negative way, the studied variable. Thus, there’s no risk of exacerbating the chronic respiratory damages of individuals with hemiparesis.
While analyzing the peripheral muscle strength before
find a strength gain in all muscle groups involved, even though it was slight and not significant in some muscle groups, suggesting that the work load used in the protocol may have been underestimated. According to Hill, et al.29 the strengthening training with load between 85% and 95% of the 1RM increases significantly the muscle strength and the performance of hemiparetic individuals on the Six Minute Walk Test (6MWT). In our study, the loads used were 30%, 40% and 50% of the 1RM, which is relatively low when compared to the study quoted above. Besides that, we used static tests to assess pulmonary function. The use of the 6MWT would allow us to check if the used loads were capable of providing improvements in the cardiopulmonary capacity, even though the pulmonary function, individually, was not significantly changed.
Though we have observed an increment on strength in muscles related to the scapular waist, which could influence the respiratory mechanics, this improvement was not enough to change the respiratory parameters. Protocols focused on the strengthening of the stem muscles and respiratory muscles are necessary in order to obtain significant results when it comes to respiratory muscles strength.
The significant increment of the peripheral muscle strength in the majority of the muscle groups assessed in the paretic side, and in some groups of the non paretic side, can indicate benefits of the resisted exercise by suggesting adaptations in the neuromuscular system, higher recruitment of motor units and discharge synchronization, sparking bilateral stimulus.30
In our study, in the lower limbs groups of muscles, there was no significant strength increment on both paretic and non paretic sides, which explains the non significant change in the pulmonary function of the subjects since the study showed that the positioning adopted during the strengthening exercise of the lower limbs, that demands activity from the abdominal muscles, can influence the forced expiration.
New studies must be done with higher work load, exercises focused on the respiratory muscles and using other tests that assess the cardiorespiratory function, which will allow the assessment of whether the muscle strengthening provides functional capacity improvement. Even though the sample studied in this work presents diversity when it comes to lesion time, we believe that this variable didn’t influence the results, as all participants had unilateral cerebrovascular lesion for, at least, six months, which is the period of time to consider the hemiparesis chronicity. It is important to highlight that overall, seventy volunteers were sorted. However, only seventeen did not present plegia in any body segment and could perform the movements required during the performance of the training program. Thus, the sample was considered homogeneous for the level of musculoskeletal compromising. From the seventeen participants, seven were not included for not taking the twelve week training.
The results of the present study indicate that the adaptations caused by the training with resisted exercise did not promote alterations in the thoracic expansibility and strength of the respiratory muscles, as well as in the lungs volume and capacity of individuals at a stroke chronic phase.